• Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • My Social Media
  • About
    • About Mark Draughn
    • Other Authors
      • About Gary Olson
      • About Ken Gibson
      • About Joel Rosenberg
    • Disclosures
    • Terms and Conditions

Windypundit

Classical liberalism, criminal laws, the war on drugs, economics, free speech, technology, photography, sex work, cats, and whatever else comes to mind.

Why Not Bail Out the GOOD Banks?

September 23, 2008 By Mark Draughn 3 Comments

This is probably wrong in so many ways, but why are we helping the bad financial institutions? Wouldn’t it make more sense to help out the good ones?

I think, first of all, that the plan is not to simply give away the $700 billion. Instead, the U.S. Treasury will take over bad mortgage investments. I think the way this works is that if the government buys $100 million in bad mortgage investments and, say, only gets back 75 cents on the dollar, the government will have spent $25 billion to add $100 billion in liquidity to the economy. At that rate, spending the full $700 billion will free up $2.8 trillion from bad investments. (I have no real idea if these figures make sense.)

Second, as I understand it, the big fear in this crisis is that a series of institutional failures will cause a credit crunch that makes it hard for companies to operate from day to day and impossible for them to expand. This could cripple production and produce a huge involuntary contraction in our economy. Preventing this credit crunch is why we want to add liquidity by pouring in cash.

But why do we have to pour cash into the bad banks? Wouldn’t it add just as much money to the credit markets if we poured the money into the successful banks?

As for the bad banks, we just let them bleed to death in the street. The remaining banks, now flush with U.S. Treasury cash, will fill in the gaps and prevent a credit crunch.

This solves the credit crisis, avoids rewarding financial institutions for their failure, and because we’re lending the money to financial institutions that have not driven themselves into the ground, probably costs less.

One of the creeds of the economist is that there’s no such thing is a free lunch, and this sounds like a free lunch to me. That means I’m probably misunderstanding something important about financial markets, and my plan is hugely flawed.

But I’ll bet it’s not the craziest plan you’ll hear before this is all over.

Related

Share This Post

Filed Under: Economics

Reader Interactions

Comments

  1. ida says

    September 24, 2008 at 6:52 am

    there are no good banks. when i tried to buy my home here in indianapolis over 11yrs ago i still remember all these mortgage brokers that wanted me to get the bigger loan. you can qualifiy for this and that just change your taxes to 9 dependants and at the end of the year it will balance out with irs. yea, right, whatever. you would have thought i commented manslaughter when i asked for a 30yr fixed rate loan back in 97. omg and i qualifiyed for a 150,000 home but i wanted that 60,000 home i was such a sinner. whatever. my taxes have doubled over the years. my finances did loosen up and i am almost paid in full. being free and clear is sticking it to the man.

    Reply
  2. Joel Rosenberg says

    September 25, 2008 at 8:24 am

    I’m not sure that doesn’t make sense. Heck, I’m not sure that it doesn’t make sense to bail out the bailable borrowers, and letting the benefits trickle up to the CDO owners.

    Reply
  3. Mark Draughn says

    September 25, 2008 at 10:20 am

    As I learn more, I’m starting to get an inkling that this doesn’t make sense.

    The best analogy that I can come up with is that these financial firms are like a bunch of cars on the highway, and some of them are breaking down. As they gring to a halt, they block traffic and threaten to cause a giant traffic jam. The federal government is a tow truck, trying to clear the road, and it only makes sense to tow the cars that have broken down.

    I don’t know if that analogy is an accurate description of our financial system, but I think it’s consistent with the argument for bailing out failing companies.

    Reply

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Primary Sidebar

Search

Chicago Metro Area Covid Status

Recent Posts

  • Ta’Kiya Young Shooting Analysis
  • Watching People Die – Part 3: Policy
  • Watching People Die – Part 2: Lessons
  • Watching People Die – Part 1: Incidents
  • America’s Rifle
  • Meet the New Cuteness
  • Jane Notz is Fibbing
  • Smarter Gun Control?

Where else to find me

  • Twitter
  • Post
  • Mastodon

Follow

  • Twitter
  • Mastodon

Bloggy Goodness

  • Agitator
  • DrugWar Rant
  • Duly Noted
  • Dynamist
  • Hit & Run
  • Honest Courtesan
  • Nobody's Business
  • Popehat
  • Ravings of a Feral Genius

Blawgs

  • a Public Defender
  • appellatesquawk
  • Blonde Justice
  • Chasing Truth. Catching Hell.
  • Crime & Federalism
  • Crime and Consequences Blog
  • Criminal Defense
  • CrimLaw
  • D.A. Confidential
  • Defending Dandelions
  • Defending People
  • DUI Blog
  • ECIL Crime
  • Gamso For the Defense
  • Graham Lawyer Blog
  • Hercules and the Umpire
  • Indefensible
  • Koehler Law Blog
  • Legal Satyricon
  • New York Personal Injury Law Blog
  • Norm Pattis
  • not for the monosyllabic
  • Not Guilty
  • Probable Cause
  • Seeking Justice
  • Simple Justice
  • Tempe Criminal Defense
  • The Clements Firm
  • The Trial Warrior Blog
  • The Volokh Conspiracy
  • Underdog Blog
  • Unwashed Advocate
  • West Virginia Criminal Law Blog

Bloggers

  • Booker Rising
  • Eric Zorn
  • ExCop-LawStudent
  • InstaPundit
  • Last One Speaks
  • Leslie's Omnibus
  • Marathon Pundit
  • Miss Manners
  • Preaching to the Choir
  • Roger Ebert's Journal
  • Speakeasy Blog
  • SWOP Chicago

Geek Stuff

  • Charlie's Diary
  • Google Blogoscoped
  • Schneier on Security
  • The Altruist
  • The Ancient Gaming Noob
  • The Daily WTF
  • xkcd

Resources

  • CIA World Factbook
  • Current Impact Risks
  • EFF: Bloggers
  • Institute for Justice
  • Jennifer Abel
  • StrategyPage
  • W3 EDGE, Optimization Products for WordPress
  • W3 EDGE, Optimization Products for WordPress
  • W3 EDGE, Optimization Products for WordPress
  • Wikipedia
  • WolframAlpha

Gone But Not Forgotten

  • Peter McWilliams

Copyright © 2023 Mark Draughn · Magazine Pro On Genesis Framework · WordPress

Go to mobile version