In response to my admittedly harsh missive about the conviction of Paul “Max Hardcore” Little, commenter “jt” writes:
I couldn’t help but notice you mentioned you’ve never seen a Max Hardcore video. Perhaps you should. Once you have, you may understand how a jury could find his work obscene, based on the old Miller three prong test, and therefor not constitutionally protected speech. The outcome may not be what you would like to see, but the jury based their decision on the state of the law, not how they–or you–would like the law to read. The judge only enforced the law as it currently exists, she didn’t make this stuff up either. If you want guys like Max Hardcore to continue to crank out their particular brand of “art,” then get the law changed and quit pissing on the people who’s only offense is doing their duty under the law and not making up their own along the way in order to get the result you would have preferred.
I’m sure “jt” is right that Little is a scumbag. Practically everybody says so. It’s one of the reasons I don’t want to see his videos.
Yet that’s not what they prosecuted him for. I’ve heard that it looks like the women in his videos are really being abused. If they are, some cops and prosecutors really should come down hard on him for that. It seems like it would be a pretty easy case, what with all the video of the crime.
But that hasn’t happened. Instead we get this federal-level porn distribution case. It’s not even a real porn distribution case. Little was charged with conspiracy, for making the porn that the actual distributor sent to Florida.
(I’m always suspicious when the prosecution charges someone with crimes involving concepts like conspiracy and intent or their after-the-fact brethren, money laundering and obstruction. Not that those things aren’t against the law, but couldn’t they find a real, tangible crime? You know, something where people get hurt or lose money? Something with a victim?)
I have to admit that “jt” has a pretty good point about the judge and jury only following the law. This is especially true of the jurors, reluctant participants who are intentionally kept in the dark about legal theories other than the official version. Perhaps I was more disrespectful of the decision makers than they deserved.
Then again, all of Little’s actions took place in California, but the federal prosecutors made their case in Florida. The obvious reason for this is that the feds thought they would lose their case if they tried it in California. Suppose Little’s lawyer had been able to get the trial moved to California, and suppose Little had been found not guilty as the feds obviously expected. Wouldn’t that judge and jury also have been following the law? How much respect does a court decision deserve if it could easily have come out with the opposite result just by moving the proceedings to a different state?
Clearly, one of these trial outcomes—from the actual trial in Florida or the hypothetical trial in California—has to be wrong, and I’m saying it was the one in Florida that was wrong. To put it another way, the feds have no respect for California courts or California juries, so I’m not sure why I should give any more respect to the Florida court and the Florida jury.
Even if I accept that the judge and jury were only doing their duty and following the law when the found Little guilty, there’s still the matter of sentencing. It’s not as if the judge was just following an administrative process. She had broad discretion over the sentence, and she made the choice she did. It’s reasonable to criticize her for that.
Finally, as to whether I should “get the law changed” if I don’t like it, I think the law is already quite clear on this matter:
Congress shall make no law…abridging the freedom of speech, or of the press…
There’s not a lot of wiggle room in there, not even for dirty pictures.
Since “jt” mentions the Miller test, perhaps he’s not talking about the written law, but about case law as established by the history of court rulings on this subject. In that case, getting the law changed means getting judges to rule differently than they have been, so it only seems fair to comment on the judge’s ruling.
Speaking of the Miller test, I’m not a big fan. Consider the first prong of the test:
whether “the average person, applying contemporary community standards” would find that the work, taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest,
How are potential offenders supposed to know what community standards are? It’s one thing that “ignorance of the law is no excuse” but ignorance of the standards of every single community in the country?
And just what’s wrong with prurient interests anyway?

Leave a Reply